The Botched Execution of Christa Pike
by Christina Yao Pelliccioni
The Christa Pike case has led to many different twists, turns, and inconsistencies. To start with the facts, Christa Pike was sentenced to death after murdering her classmate in 1995. On September 30, she was given two doses of the lethal drug pentobarbital. After she survived, she was taken to the hospital. She regained the ability to walk and is eating. She has also regained some movement in her arms, which were burned and blistered during the execution attempt.
Pike is the only person known to survive a lethal injection. Now she has returned to death row, transported back to the facility where she has lived for the past 30 years.
Pike’s lawyers say she is dealing with an unknown amount of physical and psychological harm “including the terror, pain, and uncertainty of believing she was about to die.” A judge has demanded documentation of Pike’s psychological state before, during, and after the execution. Tennessee’s governor has halted all executions for the rest of the year. It is unclear when executions will be resumed and what this means for Pike.
Not often does a case so clearly show the flaws within the death penalty. Justice should be served, and if Christa Pike is a threat to the safety of others, she should not be allowed to walk free. But how does the continuation of attempting to end her life bring justice or peace to anyone?
One of the most confusing and inconsistent things about this case is how it’s determined how someone dies vs. being treated. Pike was sent to the hospital after she did not die and will presumably continue to receive medical care in prison. But why give her medical care if she deserves to die? Either she has humanity and is deserving of life, or she is something the state can dispose of or keep at its will.
The logic behind this could be that Pike needs to die in the “right” way, but how can the state decide what the “right” way to die is? If a quick and painless death is what is desired, Pike’s ordeal has shown this is not the way.
So what’s the humane way forward? Not having the death penalty at all. It’s a barbaric and antiquated punishment that must be discontinued.
One would hope that this incident would help those in power realize this and want to distance themselves from this horror. Unfortunately, this seems not to be the case, with the Pentagon planning to live stream an execution in December.
This is not the way a compassionate, humane society acts. We must stand up against these dark instances. And we must make sure that these just stay instances. We cannot allow this kind of execution violence to go back to being the norm.
Christa Pike 2023
Editor’s Addition:
This case has some pro-life sources making connections to their abortion and euthanasia issues:
The disturbing connections between Tennessee executions and assisted dying
Cassy Cook, Live Action, October 2, 2026
The drugs used in executions are often the same as those used in assisted suicide, and as witnessed by Pike and Carruthers, these deaths are far more grisly than many realize.
Many assume that lethal injection and euthanasia merely cause someone to fall asleep and then die painlessly, but in reality, the drugs cause pulmonary edema. This means the person’s lungs fill with fluid, and he/she drowns in his/her own secretions.
But because the person is given a paralytic first, both in lethal injections and euthanasia, it is therefore impossible to know what pain or suffering the person might be experiencing.
Experiments with assisted suicide and euthanasia have also been excruciating, with one cocktail said to be “burning patients’ mouths and throats, causing some to scream in pain.”
These are not peaceful, humane deaths, whether during execution or euthanasia.
Do We Do Death for Sport?
Kathryn Jean Lopez, National Review, October 12, 2026
And I say that knowing full well that what she did at 18 was barbaric . . . After beating and knifing Slemmer to death, Pike kept a piece of her victim’s crushed skull as a souvenir to show off the next morning.
But we are not a people that lowers itself to barbarism. Unless, perhaps, there is an unborn baby involved and an abortion has been requested. Then we will crush skulls, too, and even leave babies to die if the abortion is botched. And yet we don’t treat murderers this way — we have witnesses to the planned execution, and when Tennessee failed, ambulances arrived at the prison, and Pike was given lifesaving treatment. I suppose we do that because it’s harder to look away from a full-grown adult — although when it comes to assisted suicide, we are willing to overlook that, too.
Looking at the Pike experience, the solution should not be firing squads — a more efficient way of doing the killing. The response should be to err on the side of life. Including long before a crime has ever been committed.
Pike was found to be bipolar, among her other mental-health diagnoses. She was raped throughout her childhood, first by her grandmother’s boyfriend. Her first attempted suicide was when she was twelve. Pike was failed by adults in her life over and over again . . .
Leave a Reply